New Signatures; rate/review

[KoNaStAr]

Ehh, Infamous and I chose a render and used the same one, each creating our individual signatures with that render. It was Kratos, from God of War. I ended up making one, then turning around and making another one immediately after. Both using that same Kratos render. >_> anyways, here they are.

This is the First version.

This is the Second. >:3

 

[Winged Fantasy]

Nice! I like the red one best!

1st one: 9/10
2nd one: 8/10

 

[Infamous]

Here's mine:

First version.

This is after playing around some more.


EDIT: Shit, almost forgot to rate and review yours. 9/10 for the first one, and a 9.5/10 for the second. It's not that the second one is necessarily better, I'm just attracted to it more. Like I said on AIM "it's simple but it grabs your attention".

 

[KoNaStAr]

Ahh, thanks man. I'd have to say an 8.5 on your first, I like the style and everything but in comparison to the second one, the darker areas just seem to..not fit. The second I'm tempted to give a perfect 10, but we'll drop it to 9.9 because 10s are for tools.

 

[Winged Fantasy]

Infamous I like the 1st one better on yours ^_^

 

[Zayne.H]

Wonderboy: 9/10 on the first one (Seems too grungy for my taste) 10 on the second.

Infamous: 10/10 on both

 

[GrayFox]

Chris
First one: 9.5/10 Hard to find anything wrong with it! It just doesn't seem like a "10" though.
Second: 9/10 Amazing, but it looks like the left side is cut off from the rest.

Infamous
First: 9.5/10
Second: 9/10
Mor amazing sigs. I like both of them, but I like the darker one a little bit more. The second one is supposed to be bright, but I think it's just a little slightly too bright.

 

[Infamous]

*takes a humble bow*


Thanks guys.

 

[Winged Fantasy]

No problem I like giving my opinions

 

[F.Y.C.N.]

<span style="colorarkOrchid">Chris--

First: I like the first one, but I'm not sure about the colors...it just seems like you tried a little *too* hard to make it all match. Don't know, just something about it. I give it a 7.0

Second: Better IMO, Kratos stands out much more from the background and yet it still has a blending feel. The name also feels more solid. A 9.0 for that one.

Infamous--

First: Really like the first one, the background seems to stand out as much as the render, but it doesn't look messy at all. 8.5

Second: Not sure if it's better than the first, but the change in contrast is nice, it feels not as empty I suppose. A little better, but not by much. 9.0</span>